饶
璟
叶
睿
医事犯罪中的因果关系判断———以疾病进程为考察要点
[
13]前田雅英.刑法总论讲义[M].东京:东京大学出版会,2011.
14]井田良.刑法总论的理论构造[M].东京:成文堂,2005.
15]EvidenceBasedMedicineWorkingGroup.Evidence-BasedMedicine:anewapproachtoteachingthepracticeofmedicine
J].TheJournalofTheAmericanMedicalAssociation,1992,(17).
16]张军,郭克斌,熊元波,刘晓雪.渐冻人误诊为颈椎病6例分析[J].中国误诊学杂志,2010,(33).
17]刘斯哲,樊忠喜.上消化道出血并发急性心肌梗塞死亡2例报告[J].吉林大学学报(医学版),2007,(3).
18]李燕玲.52例重症脑血管病的院前抢救[C]//中华医学会急诊医学学会第六次全国急诊医学学术会议论文汇编.杭州:中
华急诊医学杂志社,1996.
19]蔡运昌,吴强,张陈匀.ST段抬高型急性心肌梗死现代治疗的循证医学证据[J].贵州医药,2012,(12).
[
[
[
[
[
[
[
[20]KAMELLESA,RUTLEDGETL,TILLMANNSTD,赵秀敏.IB2期宫颈癌风险组患者无病存活率的外科病理学预测
指标:传统模型是否仍适用[J].世界核心医学期刊文摘(妇产科学分册),2005,(1).
[21]陈玉玲.循证医学证据在处理医疗侵权案中的适用[J].东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2016,(2).
JudgmentofCausalRelationshipintheMedicalCrime
———FromDiseaseProcess
1
2
RAOJing,YERui
1.CivilAviationFlightUniversityofChina,Guanghan,Sichuan618307;
(
2
.ResearchInstituteofLaw,SichuanAcademyofSocialSciences,Chengdu,Sichuan610071,China)
Abstract:CausalrelationshipjudgmentofMedicalCrimefollowsconditiontheory.However,
basedontheparticularityofmedicaltechnology,theimportanceofdiseaseprocessshouldbe
clarifiedwhenjudgingcausationrelationshipfromthepointofviewofevidence-basedmedicine.
Whetherthediseasehasevolvedintoirreversiblestageshouldbereviewedandthewidelyaccept-
ed.Activetreatmentofthediseaseshouldbeexploredsoastoensurethatnotreatmentcouldbe
done.Moreover,whetherthedifferencebetweentreatmentandnon-treatment,andthedifference
amongtreatmentsofdifferentperiodsignificantlyreducecausalities.
Keywords:medicalcrime;causalrelationship;thediseaseprocess;evidence-basedmedicine
[责任编辑:苏雪梅]
55